IS THE much-heralded East African Community (EAC) heading for troubled waters? Reports of Tanzania’s isolation from regional summits suggest something is afoot in this bloc that has been so praised for its success in breaking down trade and investment barriers.
The ascent of Uhuru Kenyatta as the president of the bloc’s most powerful member appears to have changed the dynamics of the region.
Under scrutiny because of his tussle with the International Criminal Court, Kenyatta seems determined to get things done in a hurry. Part of this is the fast-tracking of EAC commitments on a range of issues from infrastructure to trade barriers.
In the process, foot-dragging Tanzania and economically weak Burundi are getting left behind. Kenyatta, along with his Rwandan and Ugandan counterparts, has been holding regional summits without the presidents of the other bloc leaders. South Sudan, which has applied to join the EAC, is aligned to the Kenyatta triumvirate.
The original EAC, founded in 1976, failed after 10 years. It was a difficult time for the region, with Idi Amin in power in Uganda, Tanzania still in the grip of its socialist experiment and Kenya flexing its economic muscle in the strongly capitalist country. This time, the region is more cohesive with not just countries, but companies, thinking and acting regionally.
Kenya, Uganda and Rwanda, keen to fast-track integration, have spearheaded the formation of what they call the "coalition of the willing". Burundi and Tanzania have been left out of recent meetings at which a regional customs agreement was signed and at which talks about a new railway to link Kenya, Uganda and Rwanda took place. Tanzania and Burundi have also been excluded from agreement on a common tourist visa in East Africa.
Tanzania, in particular, is under fire for slowing down the pace of regional integration. It has often pleaded for longer integration timetables, and critics believe it is paying lip service to the EAC.
There also discontent with Tanzania’s cross-cutting membership of the Southern African Development Community (Sadc). This has long been seen as a loophole for South African goods to enter the EAC market at preferential tariffs. EAC leaders also took a dim view of Tanzania’s support for Sadc’s backing of the Congolese army’s recent military offensive against the rebels in eastern Democratic Republic of Congo.
Uganda and Rwanda were against military confrontation. They said it would escalate tension, with potential spillover into their territories.
Tanzania has since said it would not recognise any EAC agreements made by the other states from which it was excluded. But it has a lot to lose by a fallout with the region, given the historical interlocking of the economies.
It also has big infrastructure plans that need brisk regional trade to support their viability.
The EAC secretariat, based in Tanzania, has expressed concern about the rising hostility and is expected to address the problem at the next heads of state summit next week.
Tanzania may be eventually pushed to do something it has been under pressure to do for a long time — make a choice. If it is to be included in the ambitious plans of EAC countries, it needs to keep up and not be distracted by its obligations to Sadc. Or, it needs to throw in its lot with Sadc, which may mean losing out on the benefits of increasing co-operation in the EAC.
There is a bigger issue here. If the EAC, with its relatively small membership and regional interconnectedness, cannot bring all parties on board, what chance of success does the much larger tripartite free-trade plan — incorporating Sadc, the EAC and the Common Market for Eastern and Southern Africa — have?
The EAC is a microcosm of the politicians’ ambitious dream of economic union from Cape to Cairo.
It is a dream that is likely to be a long time coming.
• Games is CEO of Africa @ Work, an advisory and consulting company.